Invisible Sphere vs. Invisibility Cloak - What Are The Differences?

18 February, 2013

Share this story:
Follow us: - Which one would you like to have - an invisible sphere or an invisibility cloak?

These are actually two entirely different devices according to scientists.

For a long time the idea that objects or persons could become invisible was considered pure science fiction.

This has changed in the recent years, as invisibility technology is quickly becoming reality, or at least that is what scientists hope when developing and testing advanced cloaking prototypes.

In a paper published in Science in 2006, John Pendry of Imperial College London and David Schurig and David Smith of Duke University wrote that "a cloak of invisibility is in principle possible, at least over a narrow frequency band" and presented the first practical realization of such a cloak.

Their "cloaking" prototype was impressive but still not perfect as probably expected.

Refining the cloaking technology continues all the time.

The Duke University team has extensive experience in creating "meta-materials," man-made objects that have properties often absent in natural ones.

Structures incorporating meta-materials can be designed to guide electromagnetic waves around an object, only to have them emerge on the other side as if they had passed through an empty volume of space, thereby cloaking the object.

"In order to create the first cloaks, many approximations had to be made in order to fabricate the intricate meta-materials used in the device," said Nathan Landy, a graduate student working in the laboratory of senior investigator David R. Smith, William Bevan Professor of electrical and computer engineering at Duke's Pratt School of Engineering.

"One issue, which we were fully aware of, was loss of the waves due to reflections at the boundaries of the device," Landy said. He explained that it was much like reflections seen on clear glass. The viewer can see through the glass just fine, but at the same time the viewer is aware the glass is present due to light reflected from the surface of the glass.

Landy and his team have successfully constructed a working prototype.

"We built the cloak, and it worked," he said.

"It split light into two waves which traveled around an object in the center and re-emerged as the single wave with minimal loss due to reflections."

Landy presents the cloak.

Landy said this approach could have more applications than just cloaks. For example, meta-materials can "smooth out" twists and turns in fiber optics, in essence making them seem straighter. This is important, Landy said, because each bend attenuates the wave within it.

The researchers are now working to apply the principles learned in the latest experiments to three dimensions, a much greater challenge than in a two-dimensional device.

In 2011, Janos Perczel, a 22-year old undergraduate at the University of St Andrews in Scotland published a paper describing an 'invisible sphere' that slowed down light, potentially allowing the device to remain invisible in front of ever-changing backgrounds of different colors.

This makes us wonder - what are the differences between an invisible sphere and an invisibility cloak?

In an interview with the Voice of Russia, Janos Perczel explained that people should not confuse these two devices. "There are substantial differences between our sphere and what you see in the Harry Potter movies.

Most important of them being that the invisibility cloak in Rowling's novel is moldable, while our optical device is a rigid sphere-like object.

You cannot change its shape or wrap it around yourself. The flexibility of the cloak that you so often see in the movies is incredibly difficult to achieve in reality.

Admittedly, there are certain proposals how to do this, especially from St Andrews.

Janos Perczel

Dr Andrea Di Falco has recently come up with the idea of flexible meta-materials which might eventually lead to the creation of Harry-Potter-like cloaks.

For now, however, rigid box or sphere-like invisibility devices seem to be more realistic and, indeed, are already being produced in experimental science labs," Perczel said

Perczel hopes that if an invisible sphere will be used in reality it will be done to achieve something good.

"The decision about how the device will be used in practice usually belongs to the engineers, designers, and production managers who know the market well and can foresee what will sell better.

Imagine all you could do if you were invisible…

Obviously, our device can be used to make things invisible when needed. I am worried about the potential military use of our optical sphere, especially in the area of the development of new invisible weapons.

My hope is that the invisible sphere would be used in more peaceful ways. One of them might be shielding people from hazardous forms of radiation. Still, these are just suggestions."

See also:
25,000 Invisibility Cloaks Created By Scientists

A New Design Of A Real-Life Invisibility Cloak Much Closer To Perfection

Invisible Ships At Sea: How New Cloaking Technology Will Trick Water

Invisible Aliens: Extraterrestrial Life May Be Beyond Human Understanding

Silvery Fish Knows How To Break Laws Of Physics And Become Invisible To Predators

Follow for the latest news on Facebook and Twitter !

Don't Miss Our Stories! Get Our Daily Email Newsletter

Enter your email address:

Once you have confirmed your email address, you will be subscribed to the newsletter.

Recommend this article:

Extremely Violent Behavior Of Binary Stars Occurs Regularly Disturbing Planetary Systems

15 Strange New Life-Supporting Worlds Discovered In The Habitable Zones

Dark Material In Vesta's Craters Is Black As Coal

10 Times More Water In "Black Beauty" Than In Other Meteorites!

Spectacular Comet Ison May Outshine Even The Moon - An Astronomical Highlight In 2013

Subscribe To Our Space, Astronomy, Astrophysics, Earth and Xenology News!

Grab the latest RSS feeds right to your reader, desktop or mobile phone.

Subscribe to RSS headline updates from:
Powered by FeedBurner


Copyright © All rights reserved.

Get our top stories

 Subscribe in a reader

Join Us On Facebook!

Other Popular Articles

Eyes on Mars:

Old Meteorite Shows Evidence Of Weathering On Mars

Puzzling Martian Rock Resembles Rocks From Earth's Interior - Curiosity's New Finding More Strange Than Thought!

UPDATE: Object Discovered By Curiosity - No Mystery - It Seems To Be A Bit Of Plastic

Martian Landscape Is Not Like Our Own - It's An Alien One!


Juno Spacecraft's Critical Mission - To Uncover The Secrets Hidden Beneath Jupiter's Mysterious Clouds

What’s Going On Out There? - NASA's RBSP Spacecraft Will Meet ‘Killer Electrons’ And Other Dangerous Phenomena

New Photos Of Saturn And Its Moon Titan - See A Striking Change Of Colors!

Beautiful and Mysterious Superbubble In The Large Magellanic Cloud Observed By Chandra

WISE Discovers Millions Of Black Holes And 1,000 Extreme Galaxies Called Hot DOGS

Dawn Spacecraft Is Heading Towards Dwarf Planet Ceres To Investigate The Formation Of Our Solar System

Lunar Paradox Problem: Moon Origin In Focus Again!

There Is Sugar In That Star! Life Building Blocks Discovered Around A Sun-Like Star

First Planetary System Orbiting Two Suns Found By Kepler

Astronomers Test Einstein In A New Regime Using Pair of Burnt-Out Stars

The Universe Will Vanish In 100 Billion Years - Says Nobel Prize Winner Brian P. Schmidt

Our Creator Is A Cosmic Computer Programmer - Says JPL Scientist
Are we just a computer simulation? Who or what is the creator? More and more scientists are now seriously considering the possibility that we might live in a matrix, and they say that evidence could be all around us...

Mysterious, Huge 'Pigtail' Molecular Cloud Discovered In The Galactic Center

Astronomers See The Infant Universe's Oldest Galaxies Yet!

Star With The Secret Of Eternal Youth

Physicists Challenge Validity Of Big Bang Theory
We all know that the Big Bang theory is an effort to explain what happened at the very beginning of our universe. However, Australian team of theoretical physicists at the University of Melbourne and RMIT University say that it's time to change our understanding of this process.

Space-Time Crystal Computer That Can Outlive Even The Universe Itself!

It may seem strange to think something can survive even the death of the Universe, but that could actually be possible as a result of the laws of quantum physics. Scientists are now suggesting a new blueprint for a device, known as a time crystal, that can theoretically continue to function as a computer even...

Dawn Spacecraft Is Heading Towards Dwarf Planet Ceres To Investigate The Formation Of Our Solar System
Dawn spacecraft is on track to become the first probe to orbit and study two distant solar system destinations, to help scientists answer questions about the formation of our solar system.

New Photos Of Saturn And Its Moon Titan - See A Striking Change Of Colors!

What’s Going On Out There? - NASA's RBSP Spacecraft Will Meet ‘Killer Electrons’ And Other Dangerous Phenomena

Mysterious X-Rays From Jupiter Near The Poles